What is a Substantially Identical Outfall for Stormwater Permits [40 CFR 122.21(g)(7)]

May 17, 2018

Federal EPA and state NPDES permitting authorities are authorized at 40 CFR 122.21(g)(7) to allow stormwater permit holders that have two or more outfalls with substantially identical effluents to test only one outfall, and report the quantitative data as applicable for the substantially identical outfalls. EPA’s guidance document titled, Industrial Stormwater Monitoring and Sampling Guide (EPA 832-B-09-003), provides information about how this monitoring exemption applies to industrial facilities where EPA is the NPDES permitting authority.

Facilities permitted under EPA’s 2015 Multi-Sector General Permit (MSGP) for Stormwater Discharges Associated with Industrial Activity, are required to monitor all outfalls that receive stormwater discharges from their industrial activities. The exception to this rule under the 2015 MSGP provides permittees with the flexibility to monitor the discharge at one outfall and consider the results as representative for all substantially identical outfalls—with this exemption applicable for quarterly visual assessments and industry-specific benchmark monitoring requirements, but not effluent limitation guideline monitoring.

The 2015 MSGP defines substantially identical outfalls as two or more outfalls the permittee believes have discharges of substantially identical effluents based upon similarities that include:

  • General industrial activities and control measures,
  • Exposed materials that may significantly contribute pollutants to stormwater, and
  • Runoff coefficients of the drainage areas


The runoff coefficient is the ratio of excess runoff compared to the amount of precipitation for a given time over a given area. This value will range from 0.0 when there is no runoff potential, up to 1.0 if all the precipitation will run off. The value is increased due to impervious surfaces at a site such as buildings, pavement, or sidewalks and is decreased due to pervious surfaces such as grass or graveled areas.

Let’s consider the following scenario to determine if the facility is eligible for the substantially identical outfall exemption under the terms of the 2015 MSGP:

  • A metal recycling facility has a uniform scrap metal pile with three drainage ditches that direct discharge from three areas of the pile to three separate outfalls
  • Runoff from the scrap pile is managed using the same type of control measures in each drainage area


Based on this description, can the substantially identical outfall exemption be used for the three outfalls, or are there any differences in the conditions at the facility—compared to the exemption’s required components—which would prevent the facility’s operator from using the exemption?

The answer is yes, the facility’s operator can use the substantially identical outfall exemption for the three outfalls because all of the required components have been met as follows:

  • The industrial activities and the control measures being used are all the same,
  • It can be assumed the runoff flowing through the exposed areas does contribute the same type of pollutants to stormwater discharge, and
  • The drainage areas have the same or similar runoff coefficients


The 2015 MSGP requires that permittees who use the substantially identical outfall exception document their determinations in their stormwater pollution prevention plan (SWPPP) to include the following:

  • Location of each substantially identical outfall
  • General industrial activities conducted in the drainage area of each outfall
  • Control measures implemented in the drainage area of each outfall
  • Exposed materials located in the drainage area of each outfall that are likely to be significant contributors of pollutants to stormwater discharges
  • Estimate of the runoff coefficient of the drainage areas (low = under 40%, medium = 40–60%, high = above 65%)
  • Why the outfalls are expected to discharge substantially similar effluents


The 2015 MSGP specifies that permittees must perform the quarterly visual assessments for substantially identical outfalls on a rotating basis throughout the period of permit coverage. The permit also specifies that if stormwater contamination is identified in the visual assessment for a substantially identical outfall, permittees must assess and modify the control measures as appropriate for each substantially identical outfall represented by the monitored outfall.

If an event triggers a requirement for a corrective action that is associated with an outfall that has been identified as a substantially identical outfall, permittees must assess the need for corrective action for all related substantially identical outfalls. Any necessary changes to control measures that affect these other outfalls must also be made before the next storm event if possible, or as soon as practicable following that storm event. Any corrective actions must be conducted within the timeframes identified in the permit.

If your facility’s stormwater discharge is under the jurisdiction of a state SPDES permitting authority, you must determine if the state’s stormwater permitting program allows an exemption for substantially identical outfalls and comply with the terms and conditions of your state SPDES stormwater discharge permit that pertain to this exemption.

Learn more about how to effectively manage stormwater at Environmental Resource Center’s Stormwater Regulations – Webcast.

Highest Rated Environmental, Safety & Transportation Training

Environmental Resource Center has provided the highest quality environmental, safety, and transportation training for over 25 years. Our instructors bring a wide range of practical experience to the classroom, conducting seminars and live webcasts with expert knowledge, interactive exercises and a fun, relaxed atmosphere. Environmental Resource Center’s classes are available as public seminars, instructor-led webcasts, self-paced online courses, and as customized on-site sessions designed to meet your company’s individual needs.

To view a complete list of Environmental Resource Center’s top-rated courses, go to www.ercweb.com/courses.

Upcoming Seminars

Raleigh – RCRA, DOT, IATA and HAZWOPER Training – June 18-22, July 10-12, July 23-26

Hilton Head – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – May 22-24

Baton Rouge – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – June 5-7

Chattanooga – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – June 12-14

Baltimore – Hazardous Waste, DOT, and IATA Training – June 19-22

Dayton – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – June 26-28

Anaheim – California Hazardous Waste and DOT Refresher Training – July 10

Macon – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – July 17-19

Cleveland – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – July 24-26

Greensboro – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – July 31-August 2

Dallas – Hazardous Waste and DOT Training – July 31-August 2

Special offers for Reg of the Day™ readers: Register for any of the classes listed above and you can take advantage of offers 1 and 2 or 1 and 3.

  1. Register two attendees at full price and each additional person attends the same class for half price.
  2. Save $100 off your registration when you register for both Hazardous Waste and DOT training in the same city.
  3. Register for both Hazardous Waste and DOT training in the same city and get an Amazon Fire HD 10 tablet with electronic versions of both handbooks. The Amazon Fire offer is only available by phone. Call 800-537-2372 and mention the Amazon Fire offer. Only one tablet per student per 12-month period. Students receiving tablets will not receive paper versions of our handbooks. Payment must be made prior to the date of the seminar. You will receive your tablet at the class. This offer can be combined with offer #1, but cannot be combined with offer #2 above, or any discounts, promotions, or refunds.


Eligible government organizations and agencies: Call Environmental Resource Center for GSA discounts.

Live Webcast Training You Can’t Afford to Miss

Environmental Resource Center’s live instructor-led webcast training is the best way to get the training you need—without leaving your office. Stay up-to-date with the latest regulations that can impact your facility and get your site-specific questions answered by our experienced, expert instructors. 

Webcast special offer:

  • Register two attendees at full price and each additional person attends the same class for half price.


EPA’s New Hazardous Waste Generator Improvements Rule – May 23

RCRA Hazardous Waste Management – Annual Update – May 29, June 13, July 10

DOT: How to Ship Hazardous Materials by Ground – Update – May 30, June 14, July 11

IATA: How to Ship Dangerous Goods by Air – Update – May 31

OSHA HAZWOPER 8-Hour Refresher – June 5-6

EPA’s New Electronic Hazardous Waste Manifest – June 7

Stormwater Regulations – June 12

DOT/IATA: How to Ship Dangerous Goods by Ground & Air – June 19

IMDG: How to Ship Dangerous Goods by Vessel – June 20

How to Ship Batteries by Ground & Air – July 12

OSHA GHS Hazard Communication Standard – July 13

Underground Storage Tank (UST) Regulations – July 16

RCRA Hazardous Waste Management – The Complete Course – July 17

DOT Hazardous Materials Training – The Complete Course – July 18

IATA: How to Ship Dangerous Goods by Air – The Complete Course – July 19 


Online Training – At Your Convenience

Learn when it’s convenient for you. Environmental Resource Center’s self-paced online training makes it easy to learn how to comply with the latest regulations that can impact your facility, and meet your training requirements in our no-sweat online courses:


Customized Training

All of Environmental Resource Center’s top-rated training can be customized for your site. Site-specific training is an efficient and economical way to train your employees, reducing time away from the job and travel costs.

Environmental Resource Center® will focus the scope of the training to meet your site-specific requirements, and deliver the training—at your site or as a live instructor-led or web-based session—whenever you need it.

For details or to request a quote for site-specific training, call 800-537-2372, email service@ercweb.com, or complete a training request form online.